Reporting by Jeanne Muchnick, Rockland/Westchester Journal News
Who says Thanksgiving dessert has to mean the usual slice of pie? This year, the options for desserts and pies in Westchester and Rockland are a little more unexpected — think a gelato-filled pie-lato, apples wrapped in an empanada, or chocolate chip cookie dough served with Nutella.
Not only are these treats a step outside the traditional, they also come from unexpected places (as in not your usual bakery). Options include everything from an Asian American eatery to a Mexican-inspired taqueria to your favorite Art Deco diner.
Here are six places you’d never expect to find holiday pies in Westchester County
Gelateria Sorella, Bronxville
What if, instead of the customary apple pie, you brought gelato to the Thanksgiving table — pie-style? The ever-creative Misha Mariani and Priscilla Scaff-Mariani, the husband-and-wife team behind the recently opened Gelateria Sorella, are celebrating their first Thanksgiving in Westchester with three varieties of their newly introduced pie-latos.

Options include a pumpkin version featuring velvety pumpkin gelato layered inside a buttery Biscoff cookie crust, crowned with fluffy, hand-torched toasted meringue; an apple pie-lato with orchard-fresh Honeycrisp apple gelato nestled in a golden puff pastry crust, layered with spiced apple marmalade and finished with a rich, buttery crumble and a maple bourbon pecan pie-lato made with Catskills Provisions maple syrup gelato cradled in a graham cracker crust that’s drizzled with buttery bourbon caramel and finished with smooth, delicate Panna Bianca, the shop’s signature white chocolate whipped cream.
Order by Nov. 21 (via the website) with pick-ups on Nov. 24 or 25. 5 Pondfield Road, Bronxville, 914-202-7727, gelateriasorella.com.
Baked After Midnight, Yonkers
A cookie company from an accountant turned baker might not be your first thought for pie but if you’re a chocolate chip lover it’s one worth considering. For the first time ever, Gianna Khader of Baked After Midnight offers a decadent sea salt chocolate chip creation made with her signature chocolate chip dough that’s topped with flaky sea salt. Customers can keep it classic or choose to add a Nutella or cookie butter filling. Preorders are open now through Nov. 19 for pickup on Nov. 24 and 25 in Mamaroneck.
Previously, she offered cookie cakes, so the cookie pies are a fun twist that are baked in a traditional pie pan. Plus, keep keep an eye out for her BAM cookie cart available for private events next year. bakedaftermidnight.com.
Craft Taqueria, New City
This Mexican-inspired restaurant — which also ages its own meats — continues to surprise. The eatery offers apple pies from Pomona’s The Orchards of Concklin along with their house made Meyer lemon olive oil cake, pumpkin tres leches and forever-popular coconut carrot cake. Order by Nov. 22 for pick up on Nov. 25. 170 S, Main St., 845-499-2211, crafttaqueria.com.
Ape in the Kitchen, Pearl River

As a fusion Asian American spot, it should come as no surprise that chef/owner April “Apes” Camacho Keosky is offering a variety of distinctive desserts. Her Thanksgiving menu includes apple pie empanadas, bread pudding with salted caramel and mini ube cheesecake with chocolate crust. Order by Nov. 22 with pick on Nov. 26. 20 E Central Ave., 845-201-8036, apeinthekitchen.com.
Pleasantville Diner, Pleasantville
You know those revolving cases filled with desserts at old-school diners? Well, did you know you can order those items, including their popular pies, for Thanksgiving? Whole pies — freshly baked at the company’s Stamford Diner location and made with local fruit — include all the OG standards: blueberry, apple, cherry and lemon merengue.
The diner also sells seasonal offerings such as pumpkin pie and pumpkin cheesecake. Orders can be filled a couple days in advance (though the earlier the better is appreciated). The same pies are also available at Mirage in New Rochelle and Westchester Diner in Peekskill, which Ari Thanos (of Pleasantville Diner) also owns. 10 Memorial Plaza, 914-769-8585, pvdiner.com.
Pizza Fenice, Pelham
How about a completely different kind of pie this holiday? As in a pizza topped with roasted turkey breast, mashed potato, sweet potato, stuffing, gravy, shredded and fresh mozzarella, crispy fried onions, cranberry sauce and a drizzle of fresh parsley? Sounds weird but trust me, it’s delish — I had it as part of my “Best Thing I Ate” in Dec. 2024. It’s available until Nov. 30 and can be ordered as a pie to go (though be prepared that takes time so you should order in advance); otherwise just grab a slice and enjoy the taste of T-day. 304 Fifth Ave., 914-633-3332, pizzafenice.com.
Jeanne Muchnick covers food and dining. Follow her latest dining adventures on Instagram @jeannemuchnick or via the lohudfood newsletter.
This article originally appeared on Rockland/Westchester Journal News.
Related: Hungry for apple cider donuts? Your Lower Hudson Valley guide


















